Tuesday, January 3, 2012

Guilty as charged

One of my favourite bloggers is James Tanner of Genealogy's Star. James, a prolific blogger with a legal background, writes thoughtful and challenging posts.

Yesterday James posted a list "My top ten worst genealogy practices targeted in 2012" in which he outlined  common crimes committed by the genealogists with whom he comes in contact. James intends to write further on these misdemeanours in 2012. This post must have hit a raw nerve with some genealogists as I read a few tweets yesterday that obliquely referred to the post. I made a flippant comment in a tweet "Guilty as charged - but only on one". 


It appears that another genealogist was also offended by the tone of James' post as today James responded with, "Mean Spirited"  a lengthy defence of his previous post. James made it difficult for the reader of this second post to reread and view the first post comment he cited as he did not provide links back to them.  I don't have a problem with what James' wrote - he is entitled to publish his opinion as are the people who have commented on his post.

I agreed with 9 out of  10 of the crimes cited by James, however I am guilty of his number 3 crime: "People who copy information directly from an online compiled family tree without sources."

I wrote this lengthy comment on his original post:

"James, I am guilty of your number three crime - People who copy information directly from an online compiled family tree without sources.

I take unsourced information, add it to my tree and publish it. 

I expect that those who visit my website and find unsourced information (and I use that term loosely) will do as I do and seek out both print and online resources to verify the facts (?) I have published. 

My family site is dynamic, a work in progress, not the end point of a piece of academic research. 

I am not guilty of your crime number 4 - People who think (or claim) that their genealogy is done. My genealogy is not done - my website is my workhorse not a show pony. I choose to let people view my work in progress.

By publishing my far from perfect work I have made contact with a number of cousins who have been able to verify some of the unsourced facts I have published. On occasion people have contacted me to correct what I had published. 

If I had waited until everything in my tree was cited correctly according to genealogical proof standards my tree would be very spindly and I would have missed out on reaping the benefits that the digital age offers genealogists who use online tools to make connections.

My message to those who borrow from my tree is "Caveat emptor"."

5 comments:

James Tanner said...

Sorry about leaving out backlinks. I guess I shouldn't write when I am being an advocate.

Becky Jamison said...

Jill, I agree with every word you wrote. I work on my genealogy daily, it's online, but is a work in progress. I tell people at the outset that it's a work in progress---it's not prepared for publishing and it'll never be finished in my lifetime. But I'm not leaving names out of the database until they are fully documented. If I did, it'd be a twig, not a tree. And I hear from many with whom I collaborate since it's available online. At times, both my husband and I have been personally offended by James Tanner's comments because he doesn't hesitate to put down everyone who doesn't measure up to his high personal standards. But his standards are HIS, not mine. I've learned a lot from him too and respect his expertise, just not his attitude at times. Thank you for a very well-written post!

Jill Ball said...

Thanks, Becky.

I am pleased that others share my views.

Unknown said...

http://drharrysolution.wixsite.com/dr-harry +2348143240563

hello everyone i am TONY MUTU from UK i want to testify of how DR HARRY herbal mixture cream enlarged my penis size. i never thought i will be happy again in my life because of my small penis situation,i have struggling with this issue my life time and i could not find a professional result i wanted ,i ave went to hospitals,used vaccines,tried several herbs online ,penis pumps and all but none rendered me the solution i wanted ,i felt like killing when my fiance KIMBERLY left me after undressing myself in front of her,my size was too embarrassing and shameful imagine a 37 years old man like me having 3.5inches penis size..the world seem to an end to me when we she left so one faithful day as i was watching a video on you tube i saw on the comments of one MR PAUL HAVERBEKE testifying of this great herbal healer DR HARRY helped him enlarge his penis .i was shocked and happy so i quickly visited his website http://drharrysolution.wixsite.com/dr-harry and emailed him within 30 mins he got back to me and told me all i need to buy and i did so after 4 days i received his herbal medicine ,he gave me instructions on how to use it ,as i am speaking to you people now after using the cream for just two weeks my penis size is 10inches long and 8.0 girth ,,am so happy and grateful for his work in my life thank you so much Dr HARRY ,,i also learnt he has cure for LOW SPERM COUNT,PREMATURE EJACULATION,ERECTILE DYSFUNCTION,HIV/AIDS VIRUS,DIABETES 1/2,HERPES DISEASE,CANCER,and lots more you can email him on drharrysolution@gmail.com or call/whatsapp him directly on +2348143240563 thanks

Mamahu Adulahim said...

hello everyone here I am from United State , i want to share a great testimony of how Dr SALATO herbal mixture cream saves me from shame and disgrace, my penis size was a big problem to me as the size was really so embarrassing and discouraging, a 37 year old full grown man like me having 3 inches penis and to worsen it i don't last in sex i cant even last one minutes it was really a thing of shame my wife was really tired of me because my sex life was very poor , she never enjoyed sex, i was always thinking and searching for solutions everywhere until last months when i saw a testimony of how Dr SALATO herbal mixture cream have been helping people from the globe,i saw one MR JOHN testifying of how Dr SALATO helped him enlarge his penis size so i decided to give him a try ,we talked and he gave me steps to follow which i did and to my greatest surprise in less than 14 days of taking the herbal mixture cream my penis grow to 9 inches i couldn't believe my eyes and as i speak now my penis is now 10.7 inches long and i was amazed when my wife said i satisfy her so well now all thanks to Dr Salato herbal mixture cream,i will forever be grateful to him .you can contact him email drsalatosolutiontemple@gmail.com or visit his website https://drsalatosolutionte0.wixsite.com/drsalato and you can call/whatsapp +2348103629945 i also learnt that DR SALATO also have the herbal cure to problems like BREAST BUMS AND ENLARGEMENT PILLS PENIS ENLARGEMENT HERBAL CREAM DIABETE 1/2 HERPES GENITAL HIV/AIDS so if you you are suffering from any of this problems please do not hesitate to contact him now email via( drsalatosolutiontemple@gmail.com ) WEBSITE https://drsalatosolutionte0.wixsite.com/drsalato you can call or Whatsapp him +2348103629945 THANKS

LinkWithin

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...